BUSTER POSEY NUMBER FULL

The problem with this is that only two of those catchers are in the Hall of Fame. No, statistically Posey has more in common with the players below that, with Gene Tenace, Ted Simmons and Mickey Cochrane. Yogi Berra’s WAR might not match up with those players, but consider that he played in 14 World Series. Adjust for his defense as you see fit, but there’s no denying that he was a freak for the position. Take a gander at Mike Piazza’s offensive stats when you get a second, and remind yourself what that dude was like. Johnny Bench and Carlton Fisk, for two, with Gary Carter and Pudge Rodríguez rounding out the top four. I am intensely skeptical of WAR for catchers, to the point where I wonder if it’s worth referencing at all, but it’s a nice, tidy number, and it does a great job of showing the company that Posey is keeping.Īt the top of that ranking, you have the inner circle. The average Hall of Fame catcher had 53.8 career WAR Posey was more than 10 behind that before the season started. That might seem harsh to someone who has watched Posey’s career under a microscope, to someone who has appreciated every last one of his Buster Hugs a lot more than the average baseball fan, but there were numerical components to this debate. The conclusion: Close, but his career probably needs a little more longevity. Here he is talking about Posey in the context of missed time before we knew what Posey’s 2020 season - or anyone’s 2020 season - would look like. The de facto leader of this sick, interesting bunch is is Jay Jaffe, and he’s been wrestling with the question for a while. If you read this headline with some measure of surprise, assuming that he was already a lock for enshrinement, it’s my duty to inform you that Hall of Fame experts/aficionados/nerds have been debating this very question for a couple years already. The neat, tidy arc of Buster Posey - from Rookie of the Year to MVP to elder statesman to punchless-yet-valuable field general - is suddenly a lot messier, but in the best possible way. The little “AS” on the side of his Baseball-Reference page in his age-34 season will be a feather gently placed on the scale for several voters who might otherwise have been on the fence in 2030 or whenever.

BUSTER POSEY NUMBER FULL

The full story of his 2021 hasn’t been written yet, and it’s hard to imagine that Hall of Fame case can be won or lost by a half-season.įrom here, though, it sure feels like a tipping point. It’s been a remarkable half season for him, and it’s worth remembering that we’re still talking about a half season.

Then he opted out of the 2020 season for understandable reasons, and he was supposed to come back as that same player, just one year older and rustier. The question “Is Buster Posey still a valuable player?” had an obvious answer, but there were more contrarians willing to argue on behalf of the other side. You had to hold them up to the light to appreciate them fully. 257 with hardly any power, and he was transitioning into the part of his career where his contributions would be less and less quantifiable. The last time we saw him, he was hitting. Posey was named a First Team All-American for the second consecutive year to add to his Freshman All-America honor - as a shortstop.Posey will start the 2021 All-Star Game, and it’s still incredibly surprising. 463 batting average won him the ACC batting triple crown, just the fourth player in conference history to accomplish the feat. His numbers at the plate exploded, leading to a sweep of national player of the year awards, including the Golden Spikes Award, Dick Howser Trophy, Brooks Wallace Award and Johnny Bench Award (best catcher), as well as the Baseball America, Collegiate Baseball and Rivals player of the year awards. Posey led the Seminoles to the 2008 College World Series, the team's first CWS berth in eight years. Here's a look at what Posey accomplished during his three seasons in Tallahassee: year

Buster posey number